| 1 | Abe Muir | | - |
| 2 | Aiden Sikora | Third base, Outfield | Pine Richland |
| 3 | Alex Pensenstadler | Catcher, Second base, Shortstop | Moon |
| 4 | Andrew Angelici | | Upper St. Clair |
| 5 | Andrew Cilik | Second base, Third base, Shortstop, Center field | Seneca Valley |
| 6 | Angelo Tucceri | | - |
| 7 | Asher Fabich | | - |
| 8 | Blake Johnson | | - |
| 9 | Blake MacDonald | Second base, Shortstop, Outfield | Butler |
| 10 | Brady Wilkinson | First base, Shortstop | Butler |
| 11 | Brantley Denove | First base | Pine Richland |
| 12 | Brayden Gelles | Second base, Shortstop | Butler |
| 13 | Brody Meals | | - |
| 14 | Bryce Burger | Second base, Infield, Outfield | Seneca Valley |
| 15 | Byron Geisel | First base, Second base, Center field | Hermitage |
| 16 | Cam Grujich | | - |
| 17 | Carter Summerville | First base | Central Valley |
| 18 | Cole Irvin | Pitcher, Second base, Third base | Upper St. Clair |
| 19 | Cooper Barclay | First base, Pitcher, Third base, Outfield | Seneca Valley |
| 20 | Deacon Williamson | Second base, Shortstop | Trinity |
| 21 | Dillon Wilson | Shortstop | Sharpsville |
| 22 | Kevin Flanigan | | - |
| 23 | Layton Byrne | | - |
| 24 | Manny Beer | | - |
| 25 | Mason Hart | Catcher, First base, Outfield | Seneca Valley |
| 26 | Mo Minzenberg | First base, Pitcher, Third base, Shortstop | Freedom |
| 27 | Mylan Schweiss | Second base, Shortstop | Hermitage |
| 28 | Reagan Haring | First base, Pitcher, Shortstop | Hopewell HS |
| 29 | Ryan Hoffman | Pitcher, Shortstop | Archangel Gabriel Catholic |
| 30 | Ryan Wilson | | - |
| 31 | Santino Gratteri | Pitcher, Second base, Outfield | New Brighton |
| 32 | Steele Cotter | | - |
| 33 | Tyler Rodgers | First base, Pitcher, Third base | Karns City |
| 34 | Ulysses Robinson | Second base, Shortstop | West Allegheny |
| 35 | Vincent Jones | | - |
| 36 | Westley Gigliotti | | - |
