| Anthony Miller | 2023 | University of Notre Dame |
| Austyn Winkleblech | 2023 | University of Pittsburgh |
| Anthony Lasala | 2022 | University of Pittsburgh |
| Bryson Huwar | 2022 | St. Bonaventure University |
| Couper Stala | 2022 | Queens University (NC) |
| Jackson Hower | 2022 | Dartmouth College |
| Daniel Snyder | 2022 | University of Louisville |
| Chase Kriebel | 2022 | Florida Gulf Coast University |
| Drew Lafferty | 2022 | University of Kentucky |
| Gavin Miller | 2022 | Auburn University |
| Cole Grable | 2022 | Clarion University |
| Josh Reed | 2022 | Westminster College |
| Andrew Sokol | 2022 | Potomac State College |
| Alex Engelmore | 2021 | Waynesburg University |
| Sean McAleer | 2021 | St Vincent College |
| Jacob Barca | 2021 | University of Pittsburgh Johnstown |
| Jonathan Wetherholt | 2021 | West Virginia University |
| Luke Lambert | 2021 | University of Pittsburgh |
| Aiden Williams | 2021 | Waynesburg University |
| Aidan Shephard | 2021 | Mercyhurst University |
| Chris Juchno | 2021 | Mercyhurst University |
| Jayden Walker | 2021 | Mercyhurst University |
| Christian Zilli | 2021 | Seton HIll University |
| Tyler (buggy) Casciato | 2021 | Cleveland Community College |
| Nick Partsch | 2020 | Siena College |
| Luke Jackson | 2020 | Mercyhurst University |
| Jarett Bach | 2020 | University of Pittsburgh / Eastern Michigan University |
| Michael Turconi | 2019 | Wake Forest University |
| Johnny Nixon | 2018 | Washington & Jefferson College |
